Member-only story

The Reed Smoot Hearings: A Historical Landmark in American Politics and Religion

Efrain Powell

·2.6k Followers· Follow

Published in The Reed Smoot Hearings: The Investigation Of A Mormon Senator And The Transformation Of An American Religion

5 min read · 1 week before

332 View Claps

17 Respond

Save

Listen

The Reed Smoot Hearings, held from 1903 to 1907, stand as a pivotal moment in American history, shedding light on the complex interplay between religion, politics, and public discourse. This in-depth article explores the hearings, their key players, the controversies surrounding them, and their lasting impact on American society.

The Contested Candidacy of Reed Smoot

At the heart of the hearings lay the controversial candidacy of Reed Smoot, an ordained apostle in the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS Church). Upon his appointment to the U.S. Senate in 1903, Smoot faced staunch opposition from anti-Mormon groups and political opponents who questioned his eligibility to hold public office due to his religious beliefs.

A Baptism by Fire: The Senate Investigation

The opposition to Smoot's appointment prompted the Senate to launch an unprecedented investigation into his qualifications. The hearings, led by Senator Reed Smoot of Utah, were a marathon affair, spanning over four years and producing nearly 4,000 pages of testimony.

The Reed Smoot Hearings: The Investigation of a Mormon Senator and the Transformation of an American Religion

by Konden Smith Hansen

4.1 out of 5

Language	:	English
File size	:	4134 KB
Text-to-Speech	:	Enabled
Screen Reader	:	Supported
Enhanced typesetting	:	Enabled
Word Wise	:	Enabled
Print length	:	312 pages

The investigation delved into the doctrines and practices of the LDS Church, including its teachings on polygamy, divorce, and tithing. Witnesses from both sides presented conflicting evidence and engaged in heated debates over the church's compatibility with American values.

Key Players in the Controversy

Several prominent figures played key roles in the Reed Smoot Hearings:

Reed Smoot: The apostle at the center of the controversy, who faced relentless attacks on his religious beliefs.
Senator Reed Smoot: The chairman of the investigating committee, a Republican from Utah who defended Smoot's eligibility.
Senator Thomas Kearns: A Republican from Utah who opposed Smoot's appointment and provided damning testimony against the LDS Church.
Joseph F. Smith: The president of the LDS Church during the hearings, who defended the church's doctrines and practices.

The Polygamy Question and Its Fallout

One of the central issues at play in the Reed Smoot Hearings was the practice of polygamy within the LDS Church. Anti-Mormon groups argued that Smoot's support for polygamy rendered him unfit for public office. The LDS Church, however, maintained that it had officially discontinued the practice in 1890.

The hearings exposed the deep-seated prejudices and fears surrounding polygamy, as well as the challenges faced by religious minorities in American society.

The Impact of Religion on Public Discourse

The Reed Smoot Hearings highlighted the uneasy relationship between religion and politics in the United States. The investigation raised questions about the extent to which religious beliefs should be allowed to influence public policy and the eligibility of certain individuals for public office.

The hearings also sparked a broader debate about the role of religion in American life, leading to a heightened awareness of the diverse religious landscape and the complex issues surrounding religious freedom.

The Aftermath and Legacy

In 1907, the Senate ultimately voted to seat Reed Smoot, but the controversy surrounding his candidacy lingered for years. The hearings left a lasting mark on both the LDS Church and American politics, shaping the debates over religious freedom, pluralism, and the separation of church and state.

The Reed Smoot Hearings stand as a testament to the challenges faced by religious minorities in America and the ongoing struggle to reconcile religious beliefs with public life. They continue to serve as a valuable resource for scholars, historians, and anyone interested in understanding the complex interplay between religion and politics in American society.

The Reed Smoot Hearings were a momentous chapter in American history, providing a glimpse into the deep-rooted religious divisions and the challenges faced by religious minorities in the early 20th century. Their legacy continues to resonate today, influencing debates over religious freedom, pluralism, and the role of religion in public discourse. The hearings remain a testament to the power of religious beliefs to shape political and social issues, and a reminder of the importance of tolerance and mutual understanding in a diverse society.

The Reed Smoot Hearings: The Investigation of a Mormon Senator and the Transformation of an American Religion

by Konden Smith Hansen

4.1 out of 5